Book Reviews Civil Rights in Wartime – The Post-9/11 Experience By Dalwinder Singh Sidhu & Neha Singh Gohil – Reviewed by Kavneet Singh Federalism, Nationalism, and Development: India and the Panjab Economy By Pritam Singh – Reviewed by Kavneet Singh Relocating Gender in Sikh History By Dr. Doris R. Jakobsh - Reviewed by Charanjit Singh Bal The Construction of Religious Boundaries by Harjot Oberoi - Reviewed by Charanjit Singh Bal HOW EUROPE IS INDEBTED TO THE SIKH? by Bhopinder Singh Holland (reviewed by Maj. Gen. M S Sandhu) GURMAT CHETNA CAMP MANUAL by Dr Kharak Singh (reviewed Dr. Jagjit Singh) THE CONSTRUCTION OF RELIGIOUS BOUNDARIES by Dr. Harjot Oberoi (reviewed by Dr S. S. Sodhi & Dr J. S. Mann) WHO IS A SIKH ? by W H McLeod (reviewed by Daljeet Singh) RELOCATING GENDER IN SIKH HISTORY by Dr. Doris R. Jakobsh (reviewed by Dr. Baldev Singh ) RELOCATING GENDER IN SIKH HISTORY by Dr. Doris R. Jakobsh (reviewed by Dr. Kashmir Singh G.N.D.U. Amritsar) RELOCATING GENDER IN SIKH HISTORY by Dr. Doris R. Jakobsh (reviewed by Dr. S.S. Sodhi and Dr. Jasbir Singh Mann) RELOCATING GENDER IN SIKH HISTORY by Dr. Doris R. Jakobsh (reviewed by Dr. Gurnam Kaur, Punjabi University) CONTESTING INTERPRETATIONS OF THE SIKH TRADITION by J.S. Grewal (reviewed by G.S. Dhillon) GURU NANAK AND SIKH RELIGION by W.H. Mcleod (reviewed by Dr. Kirpal Singh) DISCOVERING THE SIKHS - AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF A HISTORIAN by Dr. Mcleod (reviewed by Drs. S.S. Sodhi & J.S. Mann) THE CONSTRUCTION OF RELIGIOUS BOUNDARIES by Dr. Harjot Oberoi (reviewed by 30 Sikh Scholars) TEXT AND MEANING OF ADI GRANTH - Ph.D. Thesis AND the book THE GURU GRANTH SAHIB: CANON, MEANING, and AUTHORITY by Pashaura Singh (reviewed by 30 Sikh Scholars in Planned Attack on Aad Sri Guru Granth Sahib, Academics or Blasphemy) and EARLY SIKH SCRIPTURAL TRADITION: MYTH OR REALITY by Dr. Balwant Singh Dhillon and ABOUT COMPILATION OF GURU GRANTH SAHIB by Dr. Sahib Singh TEXT AND MEANING OF ADI GRANTH - Ph.D. Thesis by Dr. Pashaura Singh (reviewed by Sikh Scholars at Sri Akal Takhat on June 25th, 1994) from Abstracts of Sikh Studies (Issue: July 1994) published by Institute of Sikh Studies 959, Sector 59, Chandigarh, India, 160 059 HUKAMNAME AADESH SANDESH (pp 135-137) THE EVOLUTION OF THE SIKH COMMUNITY by W.H. Mcleod (reviewed by Dr. Noel King, Dr. Ganda Singh, Dr. Harbans Singh, Hari Ram Gupta, Daljeet Singh, Jagjit Singh, Justice Gurdev Singh, and Foreword by Khushwant Singh) - Perspectives on Sikh Tradition THE EVOLUTION OF THE SIKH COMMUNITY by W.H. Mcleod (Sikh Theory of Evolution by Daljeet Singh) SIKHS and SIKHISM [Guru Nanak and the Sikh Religion, Early Sikh Tradition, The Evolution of the Sikh Community, Who is a Sikh?] by W.H. Mcleod (reviewed by Dr. Trilochan Singh: Ernest Trump and W.H. Mcleod As Scholars of Sikh History Religion and Culture) GOINDWAL POTHIS by Gurinder S. Mann (Reviewed by Dr. Pritam Singh) (Punjabi Version: pages 296-299) (English Version: pages 362-367) GOINDWAL POTHIS by Gurinder S. Mann (Reviewed by Dr. Balwant Singh Dhillon) (pages 81-181) MAKING OF SIKH SCRIPTURE by Dr. Gurinder S. Mann (Reviewed by Dr Sahib Singh which proves that based upon the internal evidence of Guru Granth Sahib, which is the primary source of Sikh Studies, "Guru Nanak had in possession all compositions of Bhagats and all compositions of the first four gurus were in possession with Guru Arjan Dev when he compiled Guru Granth Sahib in 1604") ( Printable version of this book also available at the Sikh Research and Education Center's site: http://srec.gurmat.info/srecpublications/aboutcompilationofsrigurugranthsahib/ MAKING OF SIKH SCRIPTURE by Dr. Gurinder S. Mann (Reviewed by Dr. Balwant Singh Dhillon in "Early Sikh Scriptural Tradition". Dr. Dhillon reviewed all the sources used by Dr. Gurinder Singh Mann and proves that Har Sahai Pothi, Goindwal Pothis, and MS 1245 are unauthentic) The Double Edged Sword: Fundamentalism and the Sikh Religious Tradition by T.N. Madan (published in the book Fundamentalisms Observed, University of Chicago Press, 1991) Reveiwed by Sardar Daljeet Singh published in Abstract of Sikh Studies, July 1992 [this critique exposes the misinterpretations and misrepresentations by T.N. Madan] Sikh Fundamentalism: Translating History into Theory by Harjot Oberoi (This paper was also read at American Academy of Religion Annual Meeting in November 1989. Original article was published in the book Fundamentalisms and the State, University of Chicago Press, 1993) Reviewed by Dr. Kharak Singh Mann in the paper 'Sikh Ideology Fundamentalism and Punjab Problem'. Click on pages 136-159. DISCOVERING THE SIKHS - AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF A HISTORIAN by Dr. W.H. Mcleod (Reviewed by Dr. Baldev Singh) Martyrdom in the Sikh Tradition - Louis E. Fenech (Reviewed By Dr. Sangat Singh) Martyrdom in the Sikh Tradition - Louis E. Fenech (Reviewed by Dr. Balkar Singh) Martyrdom in the Sikh Tradition - Louis E. Fenech (Reviewed by Dr. Surinder Singh Sodhi) Sikhism & History Edited by Pashaura Singh, N. Gerald Barrier (Reviewed by Ishwinder Singh Chadha) Guru Nanak and the Sikh Religion by W.H. Mcleod (Reviewed by Dr. Kirpal Singh in Janamsakhi Tradition - English Version) (Punjabi Version click here) Troubled Waters of Punjab by Vijepal Singh Mann The Voyage of the Komagatu Maru The Sikh Challenge to Canada’s Color Bar by Hugh Johnston The Nation’s Tortured Body Violence, Representation, and the Formation of a Sikh Diaspora By Brain Keith Axel Suppression of Intellectual Dissidence and how the Left-Nehruvian Destroyed Punjab by PK Nijhawan Sikh Nationalism and Identity In A Global Age by Giorgio Shani Khalistan an Academic Analysis by Satinder Singh (reviewed by Kavneet Singh) History of Sikh Struggles by Gurmit Singh (1989) Failures of the Akali Leadership Gurmit Singh (Reviewed by Kavneet Singh) Dhadi Darbar Religion, Violence and the Performance of Sikh History by Michael Nijhavan (reviewed by Kavneet Singh) Betrayal of the Sikhs by Landen Sarsfield (1946) Studying the Sikhs by John Stratton Hawley – Reviewed by Kavneet Singh